OK, with pixel counting against the NTSC DVD (non Special Edition), the correct aspect for the letterboxed 1.778 Blu-ray is 1.88. Try that setting. It's tricky because the framing is different and there's also a very slight rotation clockwise to the image.
Here's a corrected image using the method explained:
![[Image: IzpBWxy.jpg]](https://i.imgur.com/IzpBWxy.jpg)
And a screencap of the NTSC DVD from caps-a-holic for reference:
![[Image: KHX8C68.jpg]](https://i.imgur.com/KHX8C68.jpg)
Aspect ratio is 2.47. So it's way off on the Blu-ray (presented as 2.335).
Here's a corrected image using the method explained:
![[Image: IzpBWxy.jpg]](https://i.imgur.com/IzpBWxy.jpg)
And a screencap of the NTSC DVD from caps-a-holic for reference:
![[Image: KHX8C68.jpg]](https://i.imgur.com/KHX8C68.jpg)
Aspect ratio is 2.47. So it's way off on the Blu-ray (presented as 2.335).