Posts: 1,103
Threads: 26
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 670
Given 299 thank(s) in 201 post(s)
Wow. He really got a roasting!
I found what he said pretty spot on thou, as adjusting for environment is indeed much needed in many cases.
Perhaps information embedded in the audio stream would be more the way to go (like DRC flags in DD)?
From the Cinema DTS mixes ive heard, comparing it to the DTS mixes contained on a Home Video releases have held very little difference. And certainly matchable through adjusting variables on my AV receiver.
Posts: 229
Threads: 20
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 100
Given 50 thank(s) in 26 post(s)
This is why I tend not to like audiophile/videophile forums. They're full of obnoxious lunatics.
Posts: 2,250
Threads: 82
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 488
Given 842 thank(s) in 438 post(s)
Well they had a good point that sometimes they are required to run a BD through dcp-o-matic and show it in a cinema, so it would be helpful to have the cinema mix on there as the second audio track.
Posts: 2,047
Threads: 56
Joined: 2016 Dec
Thanks: 160
Given 1007 thank(s) in 611 post(s)
I think he got his fair share of roasting. His main argument was:
-'The suits' order a near field mix
-You can't tell the difference from near/far field mixes
-You can't get away with just delivering a far field mix because 'the suits' would notice(?)
It's worth noting that the near field is a 1 metre listening distance.
The Criterion Collection Blu Ray release of 'The Game' featured the original theatrical mix alongside a near-field mix that was supervised by Ren Klyce. This is a fairly rare instance when it should be the standard, it's hardly a space problem with BD50s. Unfortunately dumbing down of audio has been the norm since DVDs took off. Long live laserdisc!
Posts: 654
Threads: 26
Joined: 2016 Feb
Thanks: 167
Given 216 thank(s) in 162 post(s)
Country:
Best arguement i had was over at blu-ray.com. Everyone arguing over the exact theatrical experience. new films and old films included. Had to be pixel perfect, original audio, The blue bucket had to be included in the background of Phantasm otherwise it would ruin thier childhood memories (even though no one actually knew about the bucket until Don mentioned it)
mention 3D though and you get "3D SUUUUCCCKKSSSS!!!", "DIE 3D DIE!!", "I HATE GLASSES!!!"
Posts: 2,047
Threads: 56
Joined: 2016 Dec
Thanks: 160
Given 1007 thank(s) in 611 post(s)
Dare I ask about the blue bucket?
Posts: 1,008
Threads: 33
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 736
Given 413 thank(s) in 260 post(s)
You have to find a balance. Here I can be honest and question things. On shtv or BD.com I have to temper everything I post because 99% of folks either aren't going to get it or claim I'm wrong for some reason. But there is information buried on forums like nuggets of gold to search for.
Damn Fool Idealistic Crusader