2023-02-14, 12:57 PM
Added: Sherlock Jr. (1924)
Sources: Kino BD, Eureka/Cohen BD
Neither release is ideal. The Cohen version has a nice scan, but is over-restored and has unnatural grain. Kino's has natural grain and minimal frozen temporal cloning, but the titles are brief fragments that loop, which is distracting once you see it, as you can see the same damage repeat. Both versions have footage not in the other, with differing source quality. Despite some sharpening and being an older transfer, Kino's version is more pleasing to look at in motion.
For my version, I replaced the titles on Kino's version with those from Cohen, which don't loop, and added grain to better match. I integrated one brief shot that was only in Cohen's. I deleted one instance of ugly frozen temporal cloning, though I didn't notice any others on Kino's disc. This resulted in two versions: one with Kino's scores at 24fps, and one synced to Timothy Brock's score at 60fps.
Available as 24fps BD (Kino scores), and 60fps MKV/1080i BD (Brock score). Blanks, postage, and proof of purchase required.
Sources: Kino BD, Eureka/Cohen BD
Neither release is ideal. The Cohen version has a nice scan, but is over-restored and has unnatural grain. Kino's has natural grain and minimal frozen temporal cloning, but the titles are brief fragments that loop, which is distracting once you see it, as you can see the same damage repeat. Both versions have footage not in the other, with differing source quality. Despite some sharpening and being an older transfer, Kino's version is more pleasing to look at in motion.
For my version, I replaced the titles on Kino's version with those from Cohen, which don't loop, and added grain to better match. I integrated one brief shot that was only in Cohen's. I deleted one instance of ugly frozen temporal cloning, though I didn't notice any others on Kino's disc. This resulted in two versions: one with Kino's scores at 24fps, and one synced to Timothy Brock's score at 60fps.
Available as 24fps BD (Kino scores), and 60fps MKV/1080i BD (Brock score). Blanks, postage, and proof of purchase required.