2020-06-28, 07:17 PM
(This post was last modified: 2020-06-28, 07:21 PM by weegee2392.)
(2020-06-15, 06:58 PM)BDgeek Wrote: Hi dwalkerdon,I guess the CDS 5.1 track meant for an AC-3 LD that was never made in favor of DVD.
Thanks for the DVD capture, Days of Thunder is one of my all time favorites!
Having owned it on P&S LD, DVD, BD and now UHD, I've got so many memories of it (must have been one of my most spinned discs along with Top Gun, Bad Boys and The Rock).
Not knowing better by then, I sold my LD player and collection at the dawn of the DVD era (one of my greatest regrets).
Despite my absolute love for the LD fomart, I never jumped back on board with it because it's very very hard to come by good discs and players in Brazil. The format was never officially released over here and importing nowadays is a huge hastle due to restrictions on custom's policy regarding size and value (anything over USD 50 is a nightmare).
Since DOT was kind of an early realese on DVD, I remember doing extensive comparisons with the LD back in the day. At the time, I was a 17 year old living in my folks house with a dedicated THX theater room (ohh... I miss the days of what it meant to have that fanfare at the beginning of a movie).
Anyways, even though the LD sounded great, the DVD 5.1 absolutely destroyed it!
It was actually one of the culprits that lead me to believe that then brand new Dolby Digital AC-3 format was the thing and I could get rid of everything else (so naive and dumb). In time, discreet multichannel hype started to pass and I keept feeling more and more that these DD tracks seemed to lack something (punch and fidelity I came to realize later)
It was much later down the road that I found out about the CDS format and it probably being the one reason why this particular DVD track sounded so good compared to the LD.
Sorry for such digress, but I wanted to put it all in context
I intend to do some comparisons with the UHD DTHD 5.1 and the BD DTS-HD MA 5..1, but it would be awesome to have the LD audio back to mux it all on a complete great package!
dwalkerdon,
Can you please share the DD 5.1 from the DVD as well?
I no longer have the disc and it would be great to put it up for test againts these lossless versions to find out it they are indeed the same mix.