Hello guest, if you like this forum, why don't you register? https://fanrestore.com/member.php?action=register (December 14, 2021) x


Thread Rating:
  • 1 Vote(s) - 5 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
[Released] Dirty Harry 5 - The Dead Pool - in scope format
#1
Project info:

Finally it's up, Dirty Harry 5 - The Dead Pool - in scope format V. 2.1 final.

[Image: harrywide.png]

Video:
Original Blu-ray VC1 converted to H265.

Audio:
1. EN Dolby Digital 2.0 Dolby Surround (from the Widescreen laserdisc)
2. FR Dolby Digital 2.0 (from Blu-ray)
3. FR Dolby Digital 2.0 mono (from Warner LD [1181013])
4. German Dolby Digital 2.0 (from Blu-ray)
5. Italian Dolby Digital 2.0 (from Blu-ray)
6. Spanish Dolby Digital 2.0 (from Blu-ray)
7. Spanish II Dolby Digital 2.0 (from Blu-ray)
8. Portugal Dolby Digital 2.0 (from Blu-ray)
9. Audio commentary Dolby Digital 2.0 (from Blu-ray)

Also includes all the Blu-ray PGS subtitles tracks.

The first track is Kchrules Flac capture of the Stereo LD found on the internal organ with the initial sync delay corrected.
The French mono rip is by Shatpack.

Sync:
Any Warner BD (plus subs and chapters).

Total size is about 16 gb.

The story:
Like all Dirty Harry fans, I didn't get why Dirty Harry 5 - The Dead Pool - looked ugly on video for years. First it was released in open matte 4/3 with some cropping on the sides on VHS & LD, then in 1.78:1 on DVD, then on wider 1.78:1 on Blu (more opened on all four sides), and none of those presentations looked like a decently shot film.

It was easy for decades to dismiss this as "the director was a hack", but I disagree with all those ready-made cookie cutter opinions. First because the director Buddy Van Horn was a respected second unit director with credits I wouldn't mind having on my resume, and second because it's obvious half the film at least was shot by Clint himself, as you can see the exact same tricks Clint uses in all his films in all the quieter dialogue scenes (for example, long lens with blurry background, character enter frame, or exit frame, it's signature director Clint).

I think as the film was shot very fast in the spring of 1988 and released in July, that they had two units working jointly, one lead by Clint. The other involving the action and secondary characters led by Buddy Van Horn, and he got the credit given by Clint because he shot more stuff than the usual second unit thing. One way to tell is that the film has no second unit directors credits.

The director of photography is Jack Green the DoP of Bird and Unforgiven. Don't tell me the guy don't know how to shoot films, he is a bloody Oscar nominee.

So it's obvious something is wrong on all the home-video versions of this film. The weird thing is that the film is 1.77:1 on Home-Video, whereas all the other Harry films are scope 2.39:1.

I remember seeing the film on initial release, and not noting the format had changed. So maybe something is off with the presentation of The Dead Pool on all home-video formats. The framing looks totally bad and loose in all of the home-video versions, with tons of dead air.

Here's a possible explanation: a few years ago an industry insider told me that back in the mid-eighties, a trend developed in Hollywood where they would ask directors to shot spherical, for all formats. Meaning the producers decided at the end what format the movie would be released in. It could be cropped on the sides for TV, and either be released as 1.85:1 or 2.39:1 prints, depending on the film budget and the marketing research. He said films like Batman and The Punisher could be framed both ways (assuming you use the complete negative).

This could explain for example why Top Gun cannot decide over all the video releases what format it is on.

A Dirty Harry film in 1.85:1 looks wrong. What this project does is fixing this by converting the film to 2.39:1 scope format.

Here's a Blu-ray shot with the Super 35 framing layout layered on top.
Red is the scope framing, green is the 4/3 framing indications.
[Image: super35-DP.jpg]

Now look how the Laserdisc 4/3 closely matches the framing of the Super 35 4/3 layout.
[Image: PSharry.png]

There's nothing surprising about it, because from the 1990's on, other Clint films shown in widescreen 2.39:1 on home-video weren't anamorphic either, but spherical shot films.

I made about 100 adjustment to scenes and individual shots to achieve this, as I think the 1.77:1 version is adjusted with tilt and scan depending on the scenes and shots (some shots are short of headroom, while having tons of bottom space, and others the reverse). I also added the black and red Warner logo from The Exorcist 2 at the beginning, as the blu one on the Blu-ray master is freeze framed and ugly. It makes the whole thing feel more like a true Dirty Harry sequel presentation. I say it's pretty neat looking now, so enjoy this V.1.0. You now will be able to watch The Dead Pool with a presentation in line with all the other films in the series. Ain't fanres forum a gas?

[Image: Badass.png]

Here's a quick screenshot gallery. (old version, will be updated with final V2.1 images).

As usual, PM me for the links, contributing members only please.
Reply
#2
WOW! Congratulations Stamper!
In short: it looks just right and beautiful!

What a scope format can do for a film!

Actually, this reminds me of something I read about Quentin Tarantino's Reservoir Dogs. It was shot safe for 1.33:1 and to be released in festivals and theaters in 1.85:1, but then he was approached by someone of influence in the industry, who said something in the line of (and I'm paraphrasing here, just to be clear): you got a good film here, but if you frame in scope, you'll have a classic!

I'm sorry I don't recall the source for this and I even performed a quick search to try to reference it. But it's just an interesting anecdote to illustrate Stamper's effort in this project.
Reply
Thanks given by: Stamper
#3
Thanks. Yes there's been several sources including books (as Tarantino was a pop culture happening from the get go, many books were written about him just to get on the bandwagon) where you can rebuild the story and realise Reservoir Dogs was initially a direct to video, that got converted to cinema because it was too good. They include Quentin himself saying the first Sundance screening looked wrong with a bad format (it was probably just show matted to 1.85:1), and the convert to widescreen made it epic, despite a handful of shots clearly looking weird.

Here I have to say, it's obvious widescreen scope is the film intended format. It look so much more badass that way.
Reply
Thanks given by: BDgeek
#4
Great work, Stamper.

THIS IS CANON NOW Big Grin
Reply
Thanks given by: Stamper
#5
I'm done on small corrections based on forum members input, and will release a 2.0 version next week.
Also it will be a better encode, from a prores export.

A few funny things I noticed while turning the film into scope:

- In the opening scene, Clint is wearing the same dark red sweater he also wears at the beginning of the first film and during the bank robbery.
- The shades Harry wears are the one from Sudden Impact. Just like in all his westerns Clint holster is the one from Rawhide. I'm also 100% sure the sweater was also the original one from the first film. Clint stores all his clothings and accessories from past films. He probably still owns it in storage!
- The Scorpio theme is heard briefly during the opening credits and there are other call backs musically to the first one.
- The Saints Peter and Paul Church location is used again when the guy wants to set himself on fire (Scorpio sniper's place in the first when he is trying to shoot a black homosexual), as another call back to the first.
- Some of Harry costumes are the one from Sudden Impact and he wears them again in a couple of occasions. Why waste money when the old costumes still fit? Good old economy Clint.

- Clint Eastwood at the time was into bodybuilding and fitness, and it shows. It's the film where Harry is the most beefed up. Look at those biceps when he wears a T-Shirt!
- In some of the scenes when Harry have his back to the camera, and move out of shot, it's a body double not Clint.
- The end winks at Sudden Impact finale, as it's set in a studio set with some carnival like figures, and Harry appears kinda as a demon again, in the smoke.

- People said Clint was phoning it and looked bored in this one, but I disagree, I think he played a tired Harry that was beginning to be out of his time, and didn't really give a shit anymore because he was near retirement. He rejects being on the cover of magazines and hailed as a hero by fans who want his autographs. I think Clint from the get go considered this one as the character funeral and a final gift to fans. It's obvious through the winks at many moments in the saga, and call-back of his character legendary history through the journalist.

- I read in reviews that people are offended that Harry kills defenseless bad guys in here and that it was a betrayal to the character. I think it's in fact a character's evolution point. Harry has become so bored fighting crime over the years that he just doesn't give a shit anymore and get rid of the scum that would walk out on a technicality anyway. The Prison scene, where he basically bait the Jaws like character into maybe killing the mob guy, and doesn't give a fuck, clearly represent this. It's not young Harry anymore, but more of a predating Gran Torino like Harry.
- The ending is a twist on the ending of the first, as the guy who stole Harry 44 magnum fires six shots, and his gun is empty. Also the "shit outta luck" line, is a wink to the "do you feel lucky?" line in the first. So in essence, it brings the saga full circle. It's completely a closure for the character.

Overall, I think the film had some bad rap over the years, due to three things: first fans expected Sudden Impact redux, and it lacked a good additional 30mn + a better vilain and Clint 100% directing to achieve this and be as epic, but this was never the intention of this film. Second, bad presentation on home-video in either 4/3 or 16/9. Finally it came out in the same summer as Die Hard. Die Hard was the new kid on the block, Harry the older one. Out with the old, in with the new.

Another thing I think what must have happened prior to launching this project, is that Warner must have did a poll about Sudden Impact, and people said in Sudden Impact the best parts where the first act when Harry is in SF, is being hunted down by the mob, arrest robberies, has a car chase etc. As crazy as it seems, many people dislike Sudden Impact delocalisation of the character to San Paulo and the dark noir rape and revenge vibes. In a sense I get the criticism, as the characters in the last half of Sudden Impact are really unpleasant. On the Blu forum, there is a poll, and about 3 people said Sudden Impact was their preferred, but 80 on the first and about the same on the second. Sudden Impact is hated by many people due to it's nastiness and dark arty noir approach to the myth.

So they drafted a film which was essentially the fun stuff people like about Harry. It's the first act of Sudden Impact turned into a whole movie. However, it's more than this, in the way it approaches the character legend, and the way it inject humor to the point of parody.

Many people complained about the bad guy being blah. But the bad guy here is of no importance, he is cannon fooder just like robbers in all Harry's films. The film is not about a vilain, unlike the others. It's about Harry's legend and legacy, and in that effect, though it's less good than Sudden Impact, I think it's the perfect send off. Especially in true epic scope widescreen.
Reply
Thanks given by: Hitcher
#6
So I had to put V2 on hold because basically all my hardware abandoned me and it became impossible to complete the project.

The macbook pro got so hot the battery was swollen, and all I could do is use just it for surfing, and writing. I had to wait for the right used sale from a photographer, to get the machine I needed, core i7 1gb SSD + 32gb of RAM!

Guess what, I opened the project again, and I completed it in 4 hours. At no point the machine overheat.

Now I will export to prores, encode, and will put it up for regulars here for review. PM me it should be up on monday with all the different tracks in a good quality h264 encode.
Reply
Thanks given by: Hitcher , Plissken1138
#7
V2 is done, encoded to H265. PM me for links.
Reply
Thanks given by: stwd4nder2 , NeonBible
#8
I have to say those caps are really tempting me...

I'm genuinely intrigued to see how this looks in 2.35.

Clint did seem to go through a 1.85 phase with his first few films shot by Jack Green...

HEARTBREAK RIDGE, BIRD, PINK CADILLAC, WHITE HUNTER, BLACK HEART

Do any of these have similar framing "issues"?

None are listed (on the IMDb) as Super 35.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#9
That's right, nope they are all framed nicely, even Pink Cadillac which is also signed by Buddy Van Horn.

I was rewatching the final file yesterday of The Dead Pool, and it really feels it was shot for scope.

I think those Clint phases were for economical reason. Clint is really close to his films budget money.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#10
Did one adjustment for a v2.1 based on forum user remark, will polish if any other remark comes up, then it's going to be the definitive release.
Reply
Thanks given by:


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  [Released] Harry Potter saga - open matte spoRv 375 234,528 2022-01-02, 06:44 PM
Last Post: Hitcher
  [Released] Shaun of the Dead (2004) Open Matte Hitcher 2 541 2021-12-07, 01:31 AM
Last Post: CloakedDragon97
  [Released] Return of the Living Dead (1985) theatrical reconstruction Evit 14 5,639 2021-04-15, 04:23 AM
Last Post: TheUndertaker180
  [Released] Dead Presidents Criterion Preservation V2 alleycat 0 1,338 2020-04-19, 12:35 PM
Last Post: alleycat
  [No Longer Available] Dawn of the Dead (35 Project #3) PDB 56 29,722 2020-04-11, 10:34 PM
Last Post: deleted user
  Dawn of the Dead Ultimate Edition Volume Three alleycat 12 6,399 2020-04-09, 12:26 PM
Last Post: alleycat
  [No Longer Available] The Dark Knight Scope/2.35 Version (Quick Project v1.0) PDB 41 15,694 2020-02-03, 09:25 PM
Last Post: Stamper
Photo (Released) Dead Presidents Criterion Laserdisc Restoration alleycat 20 8,107 2019-12-10, 02:13 AM
Last Post: DeafYakuza
  [Released] Shaun of the Dead 35mmized deleted user 5 3,899 2018-04-01, 08:24 PM
Last Post: deleted user
  [No Longer Available] Evil Dead II - Open Matte (Upscale Project #2) PDB 11 13,090 2017-02-07, 05:56 AM
Last Post: The Aluminum Falcon

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)