Hello guest, if you like this forum, why don't you register? https://fanrestore.com/member.php?action=register (December 14, 2021) x


Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
HDVinnie-BluRG FANRES Projects
#11
(2015-07-07, 05:31 AM)Booshman Wrote:
(2015-07-06, 10:15 PM)HDVinnie Wrote: thanks.....i think it came out pretty good. feedback is appreciated. good or bad.

I'm in the process of dowloading the BD50 now. I think it looks great, but I would say the intro video is a bit excessive. It's very well done, but it goes on a bit. I think putting a bit of your own branding is cool, and I like the animation, but when you start getting ito the specs of the BD, 7.1 HD audio, etc, I think it's a little redundant.

Thankyou for the feedback Booshman. I will keep the intro trailer in mind for Prometheus project. Main reason I did it was to replace the warner bros intro with my HDVinnie-BluRG opener and replace the Pacific Rim Trailer with my own trailer promoting man of steel.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#12
Thank you for the share, HDVinnie. Downloaded and watched the BD version.

I actually really appreciated how this was a "complete" custom BD with HDVinnie-BluRG opener and functional menu including the original special features. The extent of the presentation made it feel like a very "official" unofficial disc, if that makes any sense at all. Smile Accordingly, the video and audio were, of course, full HD quality.

I must say, in all honesty, with absolutely no offense intended, I wasn't a fan of how Man of Steel was color-corrected for this release.

To begin with, it is my opinion that the original movie, as commercially released, looks pretty awful with the massively desaturated colors that everyone complains about. I have no idea what Zack Snyder was thinking trying to make a superhero movie, particularly one starring Superman, look almost monochromatic. It obviously screams "digital grading" and particularly begs for the creation of custom BDs.

HDVinnie's version, while bringing the colors into balance (nothing leaning too red, blue, green, or yellow), bears the opposite problem for me. It becomes unrealistic for the inverse reason of Snyder's original version-- how hypersaturated everything now looks. I've checked on multiple calibrated screens, and the color just seems too high. It varies scene by scene, but even the old Superman movies didn't push the color factor to this degree. In fact, I've never seen a commercial movie push the flesh tones to this degree. Personally, I'd be more interested in a correction that aims for real world colors or just a bit more.

YMMV, but this is just my opinion. Again, I don't want to sound ungrateful. I just don't see myself using this to replace my commercial disc. This release is well done for what it is and clearly has had quite the amount of time invested in its presentation.

In fact, I'm eagerly looking forward to HDVinnie's Prometheus disc. The clip on the first post looks marvelous.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#13
(2015-07-29, 11:13 PM)The Aluminum Falcon Wrote: Thank you for the share, HDVinnie. Downloaded and watched the BD version.

I actually really appreciated how this was a "complete" custom BD with HDVinnie-BluRG opener and functional menu including the original special features. The extent of the presentation made it feel like a very "official" unofficial disc, if that makes any sense at all. Smile Accordingly, the video and audio were, of course, full HD quality.

I must say, in all honesty, with absolutely no offense intended, I wasn't a fan of how Man of Steel was color-corrected for this release.

To begin with, it is my opinion that the original movie, as commercially released, looks pretty awful with the massively desaturated colors that everyone complains about. I have no idea what Zack Snyder was thinking trying to make a superhero movie, particularly one starring Superman, look almost monochromatic. It obviously screams "digital grading" and particularly begs for the creation of custom BDs.

HDVinnie's version, while bringing the colors into balance (nothing leaning too red, blue, green, or yellow), bears the opposite problem for me. It becomes unrealistic for the inverse reason of Snyder's original version-- how hypersaturated everything now looks. I've checked on multiple calibrated screens, and the color just seems too high. It varies scene by scene, but even the old Superman movies didn't push the color factor to this degree. In fact, I've never seen a commercial movie push the flesh tones to this degree. Personally, I'd be more interested in a correction that aims for real world colors or just a bit more.

YMMV, but this is just my opinion. Again, I don't want to sound ungrateful. I just don't see myself using this to replace my commercial disc. This release is well done for what it is and clearly has had quite the amount of time invested in its presentation.

In fact, I'm eagerly looking forward to HDVinnie's Prometheus disc. The clip on the first post looks marvelous.


Thank you very much for the feedback. This is what I need to get better at doing this type of stuff weather feedback is good or bad it always helps in many ways. I do agree with you though The Aluminum Falcon. When I did this project I redid the color grading some many times as this is my first go at this type of thing. When I did this one my Mac it looked great with my final output, but then after all was said and done and i played it on my TV after burning it to a disc I was a little disappointed in it. This being because the brightness was little high and colors in certain scenes were just to much. This being said I had to manually adjust the settings on my TV to make it look like my MAC screen. However I know know for prometheus which is about 2 weeks out of being complete that I will test on multiple screens before releasing the final project. Again though I really do appreciate the feedback The Aluminum Falcon. Means a lot.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#14
Prometheus to be released tomorrow...

Some sample screens of BD vs My Version


Source BD...........................................VS..........................................My Version


[Image: QQVIfPJm.jpg][Image: P6zkAgTm.jpg]

[Image: wWmpU64m.jpg][Image: E7BoshIm.jpg]

[Image: XN5MS3Jm.jpg][Image: 9QjZpT0m.jpg]

[Image: HLbmZzvm.jpg][Image: AdZn8bjm.jpg]

[Image: oWVyxqYm.jpg][Image: uqEM9E1m.png]


Screens are not in perfect sync this is just a quick sneak peak. Proper screen comparisons in sync will be provided on uploads.
Reply
Thanks given by:


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)