Hey, guys.
I'm currently reframing Zack Snyder's Justice League from 1.33:1 AR to 1.78:1 AR, 'cause had it been released in theaters, there's no way Warner would have agreed for a 1.33:1 wide release. It was obviously intended to end up being a 1.85:1 AR as the trailers from before the 2017 release showed, plus all the negative space on most of the full 1.33:1 AR. Only real IMAX theaters would have had it barely cropped to 1.43:1, while LIEMAX would have had it cropped to 1.90:1, so more than regular theaters and that's exactly what happened in 2017. I found it frustrating not to have the option for a full 16:9 screen, though, so I ended up doing it for more immersion into it as we no longer have 1.33:1 screens at home. Of course, I'm recomposing every single shot one by one to show what's important and to still make it look good regarding head room and stuff, showing more on the top or on the bottom part of the frame. I'm not creating in-shot bogus digital post processing camera movements as I'm not the director nor the camera operator, plus I wouldn't even know how to do such a thing even if I wanted to. I'm doing it using the UHD as source since I have to zoom in, and I'm aiming at a full HD 1080p rec.709 SDR rendering. I have glued the two parts together and removed a few seconds of black in between and cut out the information that "Justice continues on disc 2" of course. For now, I'm at 69% of the whole runtime, at this scene:
![[Image: ZS-JL-1-78.jpg]](https://i.postimg.cc/wHjccTnB/ZS-JL-1-78.jpg)
Now there is a catch, and that's where I'll need other people's input. As shown in the Youtube video below, in this scene, when Flash comes into play, several slow motion shots were vertically stretched, probably because the VFX were finished for the theatrical 1.78:1 AR or 1.85:1 AR, and thus the stretching, and a bit of cropping as well, permitted to fill the 1.33:1 AR. So my question is: should I keep it that way for the 1.78:1 AR or should I squeesh it back to more proper proportions? The Youtube video claims it works stretched as it's during a super speed moment that could translate into distortions. I can go along with that, except I didn't notice that on other instances of the super speed, so it's not really consistent in the whole film...
I'm currently reframing Zack Snyder's Justice League from 1.33:1 AR to 1.78:1 AR, 'cause had it been released in theaters, there's no way Warner would have agreed for a 1.33:1 wide release. It was obviously intended to end up being a 1.85:1 AR as the trailers from before the 2017 release showed, plus all the negative space on most of the full 1.33:1 AR. Only real IMAX theaters would have had it barely cropped to 1.43:1, while LIEMAX would have had it cropped to 1.90:1, so more than regular theaters and that's exactly what happened in 2017. I found it frustrating not to have the option for a full 16:9 screen, though, so I ended up doing it for more immersion into it as we no longer have 1.33:1 screens at home. Of course, I'm recomposing every single shot one by one to show what's important and to still make it look good regarding head room and stuff, showing more on the top or on the bottom part of the frame. I'm not creating in-shot bogus digital post processing camera movements as I'm not the director nor the camera operator, plus I wouldn't even know how to do such a thing even if I wanted to. I'm doing it using the UHD as source since I have to zoom in, and I'm aiming at a full HD 1080p rec.709 SDR rendering. I have glued the two parts together and removed a few seconds of black in between and cut out the information that "Justice continues on disc 2" of course. For now, I'm at 69% of the whole runtime, at this scene:
Now there is a catch, and that's where I'll need other people's input. As shown in the Youtube video below, in this scene, when Flash comes into play, several slow motion shots were vertically stretched, probably because the VFX were finished for the theatrical 1.78:1 AR or 1.85:1 AR, and thus the stretching, and a bit of cropping as well, permitted to fill the 1.33:1 AR. So my question is: should I keep it that way for the 1.78:1 AR or should I squeesh it back to more proper proportions? The Youtube video claims it works stretched as it's during a super speed moment that could translate into distortions. I can go along with that, except I didn't notice that on other instances of the super speed, so it's not really consistent in the whole film...