Posts: 1,975
Threads: 54
Joined: 2015 Apr
Thanks: 271
Given 400 thank(s) in 252 post(s)
Country:
2017-03-04, 12:13 AM
(This post was last modified: 2017-03-04, 05:30 PM by Evit.)
I ask the experts around here, which version is best to buy between the UK (Second Sight) and the German (Subkultur) Blu-Ray releases of
Scanners (1981). They both seem to have the same quality of details but different colors and brightness. I wonder which one is more accurate.
https://www.caps-a-holic.com/c.php?a=1&x...0&i=4&go=1
In
this scene in particular, the flames on the left seem to be overblown in the German release while they preserve more information in the UK version.
AKA thxita on OriginalTrilogy
I preserve movies as they first appeared in Italy.
Posts: 7,153
Threads: 601
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 1081
Given 1480 thank(s) in 969 post(s)
Country:
Don't know which color grading is the most accurate, but my hint is to do not base your choice only on overblown flames... I encountered them in many instances, and often they were the only shots with clipped whites (and noticeable often just when seen frame-by-frame), while the rest of the movie was perfect.
Posts: 1,975
Threads: 54
Joined: 2015 Apr
Thanks: 271
Given 400 thank(s) in 252 post(s)
Country:
2017-03-04, 01:46 AM
(This post was last modified: 2017-03-04, 01:46 AM by Evit.)
I can understand that. I have no reference on how it's supposed to look though, colorwise I mean. Any fan of Cronenberg around here?
AKA thxita on OriginalTrilogy
I preserve movies as they first appeared in Italy.
Posts: 636
Threads: 81
Joined: 2015 Feb
Thanks: 449
Given 442 thank(s) in 217 post(s)
Country:
I've no idea which is more faithful but the UK release looks way too bright to me. However, it is a much cleaner print that the DE so I just use the Second Sight with the brightness turned down on my TV, looks really good.
Posts: 1,975
Threads: 54
Joined: 2015 Apr
Thanks: 271
Given 400 thank(s) in 252 post(s)
Country:
If you see the comparison between these two and the Criterion (on the same website) you'll notice a huge difference in details (or rather lack of!). For the quality of the transfer the Criterion version can't even be considered
AKA thxita on OriginalTrilogy
I preserve movies as they first appeared in Italy.
Posts: 2,068
Threads: 56
Joined: 2016 Dec
Thanks: 163
Given 1025 thank(s) in 622 post(s)
I've got the Second Sight UK and the US Criterion, both are good and both are bad in their own ways. Strangely enough most of the Criterion's shortcomings aren't that obvious when projected. Subkultur claim to have used the answer print as reference for their release (or re-release? I can't remember).
