Posts: 12
Threads: 0
Joined: 2019 Mar
Thanks: 2
Given 0 thank(s) in 0 post(s)
Country: 
(2019-03-20, 12:16 AM)spoRv Wrote: At the end, your annotations were right, there were those pixel shifting instances; but the horizontal shift you noted in Aliens ("Music composed...") in frames 2120 and 2121 is on the source... dunno if it's not in yours, but it is in mine... I must admit you have very good eyesight to have noted this, congratulations! Yet, they are not my faults; said so, this could be easily fixed (eventually), where previous "birds" can't (and also CAN'T be produced by any DNR and/or other filters), as it was due to a wobble in the scan (I guess it could be fixed, probably, but not so easily).
After this, if you still think these kind of problems are due to my process, I can't let you change your mind, so I surrender! 
About PTP and the like: again, I have NOT posted my projects there - even if my memory lacks, at least, as inventor of ColourMatch plugin, I don't think I'd post my own project misspelling this! 
It's hard to notice in Aliens as there are VERY FEW still shots in the film and even then, after talking with you I might be able to conclude it's just the sources you've chosen as you say which would explain why it's variable throughout the different Colo urMatch releases. The next best place I could see it is in the scene between 1:19:00 and 1:20:00 where Ripley is talking to the little girl, especially in the 1:19:50 to 1:19:56 -- notice distortion in the bottom right quadrant:
https://diff.pics/1Dc83vtPoAkS/1
I never meant to imply you made them on purpose or anything, just that it was present in your releases and could've been an accident caused through post-processing but it probably is just the source chosen.
And the reason those filenames are different is because I changed them myself as I live in USA and we spell it that way. xD
Posts: 7,153
Threads: 601
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 1081
Given 1466 thank(s) in 963 post(s)
Country: 
(2019-03-20, 12:40 AM)foe Wrote: It's hard to notice in Aliens as there are VERY FEW still shots in the film and even then, after talking with you I might be able to conclude it's just the sources you've chosen as you say which would explain why it's variable throughout the different ColourMatch releases. The next best place I could see it is in the scene between 1:19:00 and 1:20:00 where Ripley is talking to the little girl, especially in the 1:19:50 to 1:19:56 -- notice distortion in the bottom right quadrant:
https://diff.pics/1Dc83vtPoAkS/1
Checked shot with Newt; shift is in the source.
foe Wrote:I never meant to imply you made them on purpose or anything, just that it was present in your releases and could've been an accident caused through post-processing but it probably is just the source chosen.
Sure, no problems. And yep, it's in the source. Sure, D-Theater is only one, but I guess the BD, US and EU, should be the same; if you have the US BD, I invite to check it out, and see if the shift is there; if not, it could be used as source for other projects (or refresh mine), even if those shifts are quite minor and should be pass unnoticed by anyone (but you, of course! )
I'd say "case closed", do you agree?
Posts: 12
Threads: 0
Joined: 2019 Mar
Thanks: 2
Given 0 thank(s) in 0 post(s)
Country:
(2019-03-20, 01:15 AM)spoRv Wrote: (2019-03-20, 12:40 AM)foe Wrote: It's hard to notice in Aliens as there are VERY FEW still shots in the film and even then, after talking with you I might be able to conclude it's just the sources you've chosen as you say which would explain why it's variable throughout the different ColourMatch releases. The next best place I could see it is in the scene between 1:19:00 and 1:20:00 where Ripley is talking to the little girl, especially in the 1:19:50 to 1:19:56 -- notice distortion in the bottom right quadrant:
https://diff.pics/1Dc83vtPoAkS/1
Checked shot with Newt; shift is in the source.
foe Wrote:I never meant to imply you made them on purpose or anything, just that it was present in your releases and could've been an accident caused through post-processing but it probably is just the source chosen.
Sure, no problems. And yep, it's in the source. Sure, D-Theater is only one, but I guess the BD, US and EU, should be the same; if you have the US BD, I invite to check it out, and see if the shift is there; if not, it could be used as source for other projects (or refresh mine), even if those shifts are quite minor and should be pass unnoticed by anyone (but you, of course! )
I'd say "case closed", do you agree?
The shifts are not present in Alien.1979.Directors.Cut.BluRay.Remux.1080p.AVC.DTS-HD.MA.5.1-ILHM or
Aliens.1986.Special.Edition.BluRay.1080p.DTS-HD.MA.5.1.AVC.REMUX-FraMeSToR.
Sure, case closed for me.
Posts: 7,153
Threads: 601
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 1081
Given 1466 thank(s) in 963 post(s)
Country:
(2019-03-20, 08:47 AM)Stamper Wrote: That Aliens shot is not the same frame.
They are two sequential frames, to show the pixel shift.
Posts: 2,693
Threads: 47
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 1637
Given 954 thank(s) in 608 post(s)
Oh, OK. You know woobling is normal when you use original credits on a film. Those were baked in the credits as they surimposed credits over the images.
That's sadly why often, the credits are badly redone on remasters, many times with fonts not exactly matching.
|
