Login

**PDB** · 2019-03-14, 03:45 PM

So sounds like the general consensus is to go the variable aspect ratio route.

I will point out that Beber’s misgivings in the form of the later transformer movies is what I wanted to avoid. Never saw the last one but the forth(?) one was nauseating with its constant aspect ratio changes.

Going through the movie so far and having done the first half and hour and the last half an hour, there is only one sequence so far that swaps constantly around from 1.77 to 2.39 within a scene.

So what I’m going to try is to smooth over such transitions. Not use the shots with only a sliver of new info. Keep it 1.77 even if cut if the that makes the most sense in the scene. Keep it presentable in other words.

**PDB** · 2019-03-15, 04:24 AM

This will be the running list of all the OM shots as I find them:

The movie starts in 2.39
[Image: WNLurPq.jpg]

then goes OM for the beginning of the flashback

1. The elves, dwarves and men with their rings, pics of the Middle Earth map, pics of Sauron, Orcs raiding, etc

[Image: TlLrEZm.jpg]

and then it returns to 2.39 with this shot of the march on Mt Doom

[Image: RQEmPMd.jpg]

2. Shots of Gollum’s hand and the Misty Mountains

[Image: k54FPwO.jpg]

3. First shots of Frodo reading in the Shire/Gandalf arriving

[Image: lypEdQW.jpg]

just a few shots and then to 2.39 for the rest of the Shire tour

4. A shot of the birthday banner being raised

[Image: sa4t3On.png]

5. Random shots of Bilbo And Gandalf talking inside the hobbit hole

[Image: Bfy8dLP.jpg]

mixed with 2.39 shots like this

[Image: dJPn05T.png]

6. Shots of Bilbo and Gandalf smoking and the first shot of the party

[Image: lINYJS9.jpg]

and the rest of the party is in 2.39

7. Shot of Gandalf pondering the ring

[Image: gqd7ixm.jpg]

8. One shot from the wizard battle (Crop heavy on the sides but more info on the top and bottom to be worth it)

[Image: aOugItl.png]

9. One shot from the Hobbits fleeing the farmer

[Image: uM325O5.jpg]

10. Several shots from the first encounter with the ring wraith (mixed with 2.39 shots)

[Image: tbYtrp6.jpg]

11. 2 shots of Weathertop
[Image: aLtfGaQ.jpg]

12. The one continuous pan up shot to Gandalf on top of the tower
[Image: tnYRqfH.jpg]

13. 3 shots from the birth of the Uruk-hai
[Image: tXA4bJ1.jpg]

14. Shot from the flashback (Crop heavy on the sides but more info on the top and bottom to be worth it)
[Image: h0l7Fsc.jpg]

15. Shot of the Fellowship
[Image: ykYb6Ar.jpg]

16. Shot from the mountain journey
[Image: fUXjLQa.jpg]

17. Different shot of the mountain journey
[Image: OCPLJBa.png]

18. One shot of Saruman reading his book
[Image: 4kE0D5e.png]

19. Shot of the entrance to Moira
[Image: FLWuUGM.png]

20. One shot of Gandalf at the door
[Image: 3TIuMnO.png]

21. One shot from the discovery that everyone is dead in Moira
[Image: P2l3UTf.png]

21. Many shots from the troll battle mixed with 2.39
[Image: lDojQMZ.jpg]

22. The chase through the staircases is a mix of OM and 2.39 shots
[Image: rYzGuCj.jpg]

23. The confrontation with the Balrog on the bridge is a mix of OM and 2.39 shots
[Image: vtV6iua.jpg]

24. The exit to Moria has some additional top and bottom info.
[Image: 8liJeKl.jpg?1]

25. One shot from the Entrance to the Elven forest
[Image: fL34Dji.png]

26. A few shots from the meeting with Galadriel
[Image: bwQDIiE.png]

27. A few shots of the king conversation
[Image: yyDknBq.jpg]

28. One shot from the discussion between Frodo and Galadriel
[Image: xacbCZL.png]

29. The Fellowship leaving on the river till making camp is all OM
[Image: j9q9awZ.jpg]

30. Frodo talking till running away and seeing the eye is a mix of OM and 2.39
[Image: wLWY1dT.jpg]

31. And from Frodo falling to the end credits is OM
[Image: QcXyOmi.jpg]

Vouka · 2019-03-17, 08:53 AM

how about WEB-DL 1080p source instead HDTV?

**Colek** · 2019-03-17, 12:15 PM

(2019-03-17, 08:53 AM)Vouka Wrote: how about WEB-DL 1080p source instead HDTV?

Do you know any?

**PDB** · 2019-03-17, 08:12 PM

That would help greatly

Vouka · 2019-03-18, 09:35 AM

(2019-03-17, 08:12 PM)PDB Wrote: That would help greatly

send a pm

**PDB** · 2019-03-18, 03:51 PM

(2019-03-18, 09:35 AM)Vouka Wrote:
(2019-03-17, 08:12 PM)PDB Wrote: That would help greatly

send a pm

Big thanks to Vouka. I now have yet another source to work with, one with only the occasional logo.

**PDB** · 2019-03-29, 01:42 AM

I’m still punching away on this and as I find more open matte shots, I add them to the above posting.

At this point I’m curious if anyone wants other dubs added besides the English 6.1.
If so I need to get them organized at this point.

**PDB** · 2019-05-22, 07:30 PM

I didn't get any replies to the above inquiry so this will go out with only English. The great news on that front is that the Cinema DTS for me and now it is part of this project.

I went through every shot of FOTR and included any and all shots that showed interesting additional information in the framing with either info at the top and bottom or any amount on the 4 sides. Check post 12 for the complete list. I covered up the few logos remaining using a mix of the HDTV broadcasts. I also gave a slight re-grain to the film as it was heavily DNR'd.

I went a little further and started to color correct the movie to 35mm examples. The colors of the 35 are similar to EE's colors and I know how much that is hated so I pushed it to somewhere between both cuts (ie less green then the EE).

Color Corrected Version
[Image: Wqw2yKV.jpg]

After doing all that hard work, I realized a certain segment of people would only want the TC color timing period. So I ran off a second version with those colors

Original TC Color Version
[Image: w3r95Ee.jpg]

Beyond that this project is done. Participating members (aka no newbies) can PM me if they want a copy. I'll keep it posted for a week or two. Here is the mediainfo for one release. Both versions should be roughly the same size.

Again I'd like to thanks babouin, Colek, Vouka and Doombot for helping to make this project possible
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
With this project done and 2 release coming out of it that brings me up to 3 release for the year so far, when you include Top Gun. Last year I successfully completed these releases:

1. Die Hard 3
2. Tombstone
3. Flash Gordon
4. Predator
5. Mad Max 3

I'd like to break that record of 5 so what I am going to do is try to finish up and release most of the projects I have, including the three big ones (MM2, Aliens and Blade Runner) and some smaller ones that have been kicking around. So expect more projects being posted.

**PDB** · 2019-05-31, 09:55 PM

Last call, any other takers?

Login
Username:
Password:	Lost Password?
	Remember me

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread		Author	Replies	Views	Last Post
	[Released] No Time To Die (IMAX/Open Matte/Scope)	Hitcher	19	1,319	2024-12-01, 12:20 PM Last Post: SHM
	[Released] Alien: Covenant - IMAX/Open Matte/2.40:1 VAR Hybrid	Hitcher	16	7,040	2024-10-22, 01:28 PM Last Post: Deliya
	44rh1n’s “The Fellowship of the Ring” Extended Edition Color Restoration	44rh1n	42	34,512	2024-10-09, 07:20 PM Last Post: JohnM73
	[No Longer Available]Aliens SE, TV and Theatrical Cut (Japanese WOWOW HDTV Broadcast)	PDB	80	47,285	2024-10-03, 05:46 AM Last Post: kiyoakiwah
	Prometheus (2012) - Open Matte/Hybrid	maxwell_kennedy	4	615	2024-09-28, 06:53 PM Last Post: maxwell_kennedy
	[Released] Showgirls - Remastered Open Matte - Cinema Polish	Colek	40	37,101	2024-09-04, 09:48 PM Last Post: Quint
	No Country for Old Men (2007) - Open Matte/Hybrid	maxwell_kennedy	3	514	2024-08-24, 11:00 PM Last Post: Inq81
	Se7en (1995) - Remastered - Open Matte - Hybrid	maxwell_kennedy	1	398	2024-08-20, 01:58 PM Last Post: maxwell_kennedy
	Alita: Battle Angel (2019) - Open Matte/Hybrid	maxwell_kennedy	0	261	2024-08-20, 12:24 PM Last Post: maxwell_kennedy
	[No Longer Available] The Hitcher Regrade and Video Fix	PDB	28	15,295	2024-06-21, 05:06 PM Last Post: Hitcher