Hello guest, if you like this forum, why don't you register? https://fanrestore.com/member.php?action=register (December 14, 2021) x


Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
open matte & full screen main thread
#91
(2018-12-24, 10:42 PM)spoRv Wrote: You can see the feet of the droid on the right.

Nevermind... just (re)discovered that HDTV has a different frame size than BD... actually, Disney Channel broadcast used the BD master, just cropped on both side...

Yet to find out EP2 and EP3 open matte - if they exist, and they should...
Reply
Thanks given by:
#92
(2018-01-28, 01:03 PM)spoRv Wrote:
The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring - OAR 2.40:1

FS: DVD
OM: HDTV, WEB(?)
OAR: BD, DVD

The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - OAR 2.40:1

FS: DVD
OM: HDTV, WEB(?)
OAR: BD, DVD

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King - OAR 2.40:1

FS: DVD
OM: HDTV, WEB(?)
OAR: BD, DVD

Where does one find the 4:3 and Open Matte versions? Big Grin
Reply
Thanks given by:
#93
(2019-01-08, 08:04 AM)spoRv Wrote:
(2019-01-08, 04:05 AM)SpaceBlackKnight Wrote: Weren't Star Wars Episodes II and III shot in 16:9 HDCAM (which is Super-35 like and has a native ratio of about 1.78:1) and finished digitally? I remember seeing II on TNT a few years ago and looked like a mix of slightly opened up shots and completely zoomed in ones.

AFAIK yes!

Proofs: EP III - top BD, bottom extended scenes from BD

[Image: 86f6af31129e491b259f04d281571744.jpg]
[Image: a0e6b0561f702ec77b449cc992aa0f3d.jpg]

[Image: 4dfc712b2134ef7e033449d68fb8607a.jpg]
[Image: 207d94fa98cc239e26bd30d41fbb8b72.jpg]

it will be great to get those HDTV recordings!

I just watched the first hour of an EP III HDTV recording in 16:9 and I could not find any open matte shots.
Those two shots in particular were cropped.

I also have an EP II recording that I will try to validate soon.  If anyone knows any specific shots that might be opened that would greatly help.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#94
Thanks for checking this, and also EP II!

Apart full open matte - like in the screenshots taken from the BD extended scenes - there is a small chance that the cropped HDTV version has a bit more lines on top and bottom...
Reply
Thanks given by:
#95
I quickly went trough a bunch of random shots from my recording of EP II and I could not find any open matte ones, not even by a few lines.

For reference, these are the new 2015 versions without the 20th Century Fox Fanfare. Maybe an older 16:9 version was opened.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#96
I can say for sure the fullscreen prequel DVD's don't have the mattes opened up. I would think it would have cost more to render FX for stuff that was going to be cropped anyway.


I have the open matte Laserdisc of Phantasm II if there's any interest in that.
Reply
Thanks given by:
#97
My collection comparsion. I upload it earlier on polish forum about movies so... some text are in polish Wink

Ja siedzę w 4:3 dużo to dam listę swoją gdzie w 4:3 więcej widać góra dół niż 16:9 ale to czasami inne kadrowanie czasami zostawienie open matte:

Moje 4:3 fullscreen DVD:

1. Cobra NTSC DVD Fullscreen vs BD

[Image: d1ycZl1.jpg]

2. Back To The Future I, II, III NTSC DVD Fullscreen vs Widescreen

[Image: Nb3x1aJ.jpg]

weźcie pokaż obrazek i na pełnym ekranie lepiej widać / take „show picture” for big size

3. Beetlejuice 1988 UK DVD obie wersje Fullscreen/Widescreen na jednej płycie - płyta dwustronna

DVD UK 4:3 vs BD

[Image: JRXCvW3.jpg]

4. Nothing But Trouble 1991 NTSC vs Valkenvania 1991 wydanie GER Widescreen

[Image: l28Imx4.jpg]

5. Spies Like US 1985 NTSC vs BD

[Image: Q5xnAo0.jpg]

6. Funny Farm 1988 NTSC

7. Jurassic Park 1993 NTS Fullscreen

DVD NTSC FS vs BD

[Image: SP6jCra.jpg]

8. Predator 1987 BD vs Fullscreen DVD NTSC

[Image: EdPxQsg.jpg]

9. T2 Kinowa Russian DVD Fullscreen vs Polish DVD PAL

https://imgur.com/u1lpKKO coś się pierniczy jak dam miniaturkę / just click link to see image on imgur

10. Abyss 1989 FS NTSC DVD vs WS NTSC DVD

[Image: 73UoONI.jpg]

11. Robocop 1987 BD vs Kinowa SATRip Fullscreen:

[Image: UxqqE1i.jpg]

12. Tequila Sunrise 1988 NTSC Fullscreen ws Widescreen DVD

[Image: gVGYKEK.png]

13. Total Recall 1990 NTSC DVD Fullscreen vs BD remaster

[Image: T8CZdAs.jpg]

NTSC DVD FS vs QDVD PAL WS

[Image: bTujEDT.jpg]

14. Tajemnice L.A DVD Fullscreen nie wiem jakie to wydanie tylko ISO znalazłem:

[Image: nqw6swX.jpg]

15. Kickboxer 1989 NTSC DVD vs WS DVD PAL

[Image: gCQxLjU.jpg]

16. Lionheart 1990 NTSC DVD vs WS DVD PAL

[Image: gpwPBvB.jpg]

17. Dirty Dancing 1988 NTSC DVD vs BD

[Image: WlUr5kR.jpg]

18. Hard to Kill 1990 PAL DVD FS vs WS DVD płyta dwustronna

[Image: 3HAD1Au.jpg]

19. Jingle all the Way 1996 NTSC DVD vs BD

[Image: LGXwYRz.jpg]

20. Army of One 1993 NTSC DVD vs BD

[Image: 7e2L3c2.jpg]

21. Mosquito Coast 1986 NTSC DVD

22. No Way Out 1987 NTSC DVD vs BD

[Image: AsL8KPU.jpg]

23. Split Second 1992 BD vs NTSC DVD

[Image: 9RWXKQ5.jpg]

24. No Retreat No Surrender 1986 BD vs NTSC DVD

[Image: rLrCOlh.jpg]

25. Bloodsport 1988 Laserdisc NTSC vs DVD PAL

[Image: 88TnPIG.jpg]

26. Weekend At Bernies 1989 DVD PAL FS vs BD

[Image: jhkxw8Q.jpg]

27. Mask 1994 DVD NTSC 4:3 vs BD

[Image: 0ARtKip.jpg]

28. Return of The Living Dead 1985 DVD NTSC 4:3 vs 16:9

http://www.dvdexotica.com/2016/03/the-es...d-dvd.html

DVD NTSC MGM 2002 fullscreen vs BD Scream Factory 2016 2k

[Image: rotldc1oldb.png]

[Image: rotldc1scream2k.png]

[Image: rotldc2oldb.png]

[Image: rotldc2scream2k.png]

Return Of the Living Dead 3:

http://www.dvdexotica.com/2015/01/what-t...ead-3.html
Reply
Thanks given by: interaser , nat , spoRv
#98
National Lampoons Vacation 1983 DVD NTSC FS Snapper vs BD from bluray.com:

[Image: OnNyhiJ.jpg]
Reply
Thanks given by: Hitcher , Bigrob , spoRv
#99
The Fugative 1993 DVD NTSC FS vs BD:

[Image: zJGsFeE.jpg]
Reply
Thanks given by: nat , spoRv
Anaconda 1997 DVD NTSC FS (bothside DVD on other side is 2.35:1) vs BD:

https://imgur.com/iWlj3CH
Reply
Thanks given by: alexpeden2000 , spoRv


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Sabrina (1995) Open Matte HDTV Falcon 0 500 2023-09-17, 01:17 PM
Last Post: Falcon
  [Help] Running Man 35mm open matte Stamper 50 20,147 2023-06-03, 12:21 AM
Last Post: Gieferg
  [Request] Top Gun (1986): Ultimate Open Matte Version Hydra Spectre 9 2,570 2023-03-15, 10:18 AM
Last Post: Hydra Spectre
  [Request] Sonic the Hedgehog Movies (2020-2022) Open Matte Hydra Spectre 0 698 2023-02-27, 12:51 PM
Last Post: Hydra Spectre
  (Request) Full Metal Jacket 1999 DVD CloakedDragon97 1 1,273 2022-11-30, 09:08 AM
Last Post: axeyou
  [Idea] The Matrix Resurrection (partly open matte) spoRv 6 2,238 2021-12-29, 10:20 AM
Last Post: Valeyard
  Deja Vu (2006) Open Matte Hitcher 6 3,136 2021-11-08, 05:52 PM
Last Post: Hitcher
  [Cancelled] Ferris Bueller's Day Off - Open Matte Hitcher 7 4,034 2021-03-22, 04:02 PM
Last Post: PDB
  [Request] Eraserhead (1977) - Open Matte Preservation. simpjake1999 10 4,755 2020-11-23, 05:56 PM
Last Post: simpjake1999
  [Help] Taking a crack at my first open matte. Is there a better way? (example attached) CORTICALSYSTEMS 8 3,813 2020-10-08, 08:10 PM
Last Post: CORTICALSYSTEMS

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)