Posts: 2,624
Threads: 44
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 1535
Given 912 thank(s) in 582 post(s)
2015-05-25, 11:08 AM
(This post was last modified: 2015-05-25, 09:11 PM by Stamper.)
OK will up.
I checked MM3 different versions I have. Sadly, the HDnet broadcast is mostly the same as the Blu-ray. Whites are blown out that aren't on the DVD.
I also noticed they DNRed tons of dust out of the frames during the final chase. That Blu-ray is a piece of revisitation shite.
To sum it up, the original trilogy on Blu is the pits.
There are possibilities to fix MM and MM2, but unless an HDTV of 3 with the same master as the DVD exists (ie no dust erased from the images, no blown out whites that look like the film was made by an amateur director of photography), 3 is not salvageable. Unless we upscale the Pal DVD after having converted it to 23.976fps and you somehow get to mix luma and chroma of both the BR and the DVD. Which would be the ideal version.
Here I matched two frames from MM3 as best as I could. They aren't exact as it is a moving shot, but you get the idea. On the Blu-ray, all the metal bars on the window of the car are gone; erased out! Even the tissue over the window on the left disappear.
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/128616
You might think this shot is a bit low on contrast on the DVD, but it's not.There's sand dust blowing all over Ironbar thus it looks a bit greyish. But by jacking up the contrast on the Blu-ray, they got rid of the dust so that we could see Ironbar better, and thus got rid of detail all over the image. The Blu-ray is that way in most shots of the final chase.
This calls for a replacement program. It's bad. Warner remastering people do not care at all about this series.
Posts: 3,251
Threads: 175
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 1342
Given 931 thank(s) in 470 post(s)
Country: 
Yeah that's pretty bad, they keep screwing up movies left and right. Be nice to find a 35mm
Film Addict
Posts: 9
Threads: 2
Joined: 2015 Mar
Thanks: 0
Given 0 thank(s) in 0 post(s)
I love the Laserdisc The Road Warrior color regrade, PDB, and I think it is better than the official Blu-Ray. It has a filmic look, because I live in Australia and I think the 1999 DVD and Laserdisc version prefers the Australian look.
Keep up the good work!
Posts: 1,096
Threads: 26
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 652
Given 294 thank(s) in 196 post(s)
I had no idea all these were in such a mess!
Mad Max 2 was recently screened at SXSW (I think it is mentioned earlier in the thread) http://www.aintitcool.com/node/70747 and was a restored 35mm print. Is there any more information on this? Were there any lucky FanResers at the showing?
Did anybody catch the small run in the uk of Mad Max 1 & 2 with Fury Roads release? We're they new prints?
Maybe with the critical acclaim Fury Road is getting across the board there is hope for these classics outside of us Fans.
Posts: 412
Threads: 17
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 266
Given 224 thank(s) in 112 post(s)
Country: 
The UK double bill were DCPs from the studio digital masters - they had the BD colour timing.
Posts: 2,624
Threads: 44
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 1535
Given 912 thank(s) in 582 post(s)
Yes, that's horrible. It's revisiting the film not in the intended look. (Yet alone mix)
Posts: 1,096
Threads: 26
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 652
Given 294 thank(s) in 196 post(s)
2015-05-26, 05:14 PM
(This post was last modified: 2015-05-26, 05:22 PM by CSchmidlapp.)
(2015-05-26, 03:57 PM)Stamper Wrote: Yes, that's horrible. It's revisiting the film not in the intended look. (Yet alone mix) Like you said before 1 & 2 are fixable with PDB's version of Road Warrior showing what can be done.
Thunderdome is a bit of a shocker!
There was a 720p HDTV version floating around I saw a couple of years ago, I believe it was a HDNet release.
EDIT: There is a 14GB 1080i HDTV release on RUTracker, anybody know anything about this version?
Posts: 3,251
Threads: 175
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 1342
Given 931 thank(s) in 470 post(s)
Country:
Good question, i wondered my self what the 14gb hdtv capture is like. Only one way to find out. 
Film Addict
Posts: 1,096
Threads: 26
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 652
Given 294 thank(s) in 196 post(s)
2015-05-26, 06:15 PM
(This post was last modified: 2015-05-26, 06:19 PM by CSchmidlapp.)
(2015-05-26, 06:10 PM)DoomBot Wrote: Good question, i wondered my self what the 14gb hdtv capture is like. Only one way to find out.
It's probably the same one from HDNet that Stamper has already talked about but worth a try.
Let me know good sir.
Posts: 4,980
Threads: 173
Joined: 2015 Jan
Thanks: 2981
Given 2855 thank(s) in 1255 post(s)
Country:
(2015-05-25, 11:08 AM)Stamper Wrote: OK will up.
I checked MM3 different versions I have. Sadly, the HDnet broadcast is mostly the same as the Blu-ray. Whites are blown out that aren't on the DVD.
I also noticed they DNRed tons of dust out of the frames during the final chase. That Blu-ray is a piece of revisitation shite.
To sum it up, the original trilogy on Blu is the pits.
There are possibilities to fix MM and MM2, but unless an HDTV of 3 with the same master as the DVD exists (ie no dust erased from the images, no blown out whites that look like the film was made by an amateur director of photography), 3 is not salvageable. Unless we upscale the Pal DVD after having converted it to 23.976fps and you somehow get to mix luma and chroma of both the BR and the DVD. Which would be the ideal version.
Here I matched two frames from MM3 as best as I could. They aren't exact as it is a moving shot, but you get the idea. On the Blu-ray, all the metal bars on the window of the car are gone; erased out! Even the tissue over the window on the left disappear.
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/128616
You might think this shot is a bit low on contrast on the DVD, but it's not.There's sand dust blowing all over Ironbar thus it looks a bit greyish. But by jacking up the contrast on the Blu-ray, they got rid of the dust so that we could see Ironbar better, and thus got rid of detail all over the image. The Blu-ray is that way in most shots of the final chase.
This calls for a replacement program. It's bad. Warner remastering people do not care at all about this series.
Thanks for uploading Stamper. I just rented the MGM DVD, so I can take a look at that too.
Agreed with Stamper that Blu-ray is a mess. Here are some more pics of the blown-out contrast:
http://caps-a-holic.com/hd_vergleiche/mu...#vergleich
Look at the blue skies, the rope and metal work.
Besides the issues that Stamper mentioned, there is also a lot of telecine wobble in the transfer. For example, if you look at the credits on the Blu-ray you will see the credits slight shifting all over the place. Not sure how to fix all that.
(2015-05-25, 10:53 PM)DoomBot Wrote: Yeah that's pretty bad, they keep screwing up movies left and right. Be nice to find a 35mm
Also agree with Doombot.
(2015-05-26, 11:20 AM)Benclank01 Wrote: I love the Laserdisc The Road Warrior color regrade, PDB, and I think it is better than the official Blu-Ray. It has a filmic look, because I live in Australia and I think the 1999 DVD and Laserdisc version prefers the Australian look.
Keep up the good work!
Thanks, Benclank. I'm shooting for something a bit in-between the DVD and LD, hopefully people will like it.
(2015-05-26, 05:14 PM)CSchmidlapp Wrote: (2015-05-26, 03:57 PM)Stamper Wrote: Yes, that's horrible. It's revisiting the film not in the intended look. (Yet alone mix) Like you said before 1 & 2 are fixable with PDB's version of Road Warrior showing what can be done.
Thunderdome is a bit of a shocker!
There was a 720p HDTV version floating around I saw a couple of years ago, I believe it was a HDNet release.
EDIT: There is a 14GB 1080i HDTV release on RUTracker, anybody know anything about this version?
Thanks, CSchmidapp. I think I got all the version from rutracker a while back and they were the same HD master as the BR. I could be wrong and please let me know if I'm wrong, Doombot.
|
