[Proposal] Robin Hood - Prince of Thieves (1991) - Theatrical Cut
|
[Proposal] Robin Hood - Prince of Thieves (1991) - Theatrical Cut
|
Posts: 7,151
Threads: 601 Joined: 2015 Jan Thanks: 1081
Given 1497 thank(s) in 969 post(s) Country: 
2015-06-25, 02:44 AM
It seems there is quite an interest on obtaining the TC cut of this film in HDTV, but I can assure you is a real mess, and it SHOULD be improved somehow... it's on my usual project drawer, but I can think to take it out, because I'd like to do it before Team Blu...
 Color grading: I'm thinking to use laserdisc as reference, what do you think? 
Posts: 5,153
Threads: 182 Joined: 2015 Jan Thanks: 3569
Given 3251 thank(s) in 1367 post(s) Country: 
2015-06-25, 04:47 AM
(2015-06-25, 02:44 AM)spoRv Wrote: It seems there is quite an interest on obtaining the TC cut of this film in HDTV, but I can assure you is a real mess, and it SHOULD be improved somehow... it's on my usual project drawer, but I can think to take it out, because I'd like to do it before Team Blu... I'm down for that 
Posts: 3,369
Threads: 179 Joined: 2015 Jan Thanks: 1656
Given 1075 thank(s) in 538 post(s) Country:
Posts: 459
Threads: 29 Joined: 2015 May Thanks: 69
Given 85 thank(s) in 71 post(s) Country:
2015-06-25, 05:57 AM
Is the HDTV version that's in bad condition or are all theatrical cut prints in that pink tint?
Posts: 7,151
Threads: 601 Joined: 2015 Jan Thanks: 1081
Given 1497 thank(s) in 969 post(s) Country:
2015-06-25, 03:14 PM
Don't know about theatrical prints, but the HDTV is... but, there is also a 35mm available to eventually transfer!
Posts: 459
Threads: 29 Joined: 2015 May Thanks: 69
Given 85 thank(s) in 71 post(s) Country:
I could of course just compare some frames to the old letterboxed DVD...
Btw, I've seen some of the 1080p HDTV version now... and it isn't great. 13.3gb for a 2 hour+ movie is just not enough to keep the picture sharp and block free. I'm starting to wonder if the best answer, barring a 35mm transfer, might be a reconstruction. Edit: I don't have anything set up to screen cap VHS, but here is the theatrical cut DVD vs HDTV... DVD resized to fix AR, HDTV shrunk to 480p. We're just comparing color after all. [Image: 01%20DVD_resize.jpg] [Image: 01%20HDTV_resize.jpg] [Image: 02%20DVD_resize.jpg] [Image: 02%20HDTV_resize.jpg] [Image: 03%20DVD_resize.jpg] [Image: 03%20HDTV_resize.jpg] Not a matching shot, but here is a BD Extended Cut screenie for comparison: [Image: 1364_2.jpg] 
2015-06-29, 04:50 AM
Absolutely, yes! I have fond memories of this film from my childhood and would love to see a quality version of the theatrical version. :-)
Posts: 7,151
Threads: 601 Joined: 2015 Jan Thanks: 1081
Given 1497 thank(s) in 969 post(s) Country:
2017-05-05, 04:40 PM
It's time to start this project for real!
I think the best way is to use the Blu-ray as main source, and HDTV for those few scenes not present in the Extended Cut; when properly cleaned, Cinemax is not that bad, almost comparable to TMC, which has that nasty logo... combined together, I think it's possible to obtain a quite good compromise for those scenes - not that BD is a stellar HD material, by the way. There are three color gradings, BD, HDTV, SD (DVD/LD); the latter is clearly too magenta and dark, while the BD seems to bright, tealized and with some "neon greens" - it has also magenta left in the whites, like in clouds; the HDTV seems to have the most pleasing and balanced colors. The LD open matte is a nice alternative. Blu-ray ![[Image: Robin_Hood_019606_BD.jpg]](https://s22.postimg.cc/emo5f9yg1/Robin_Hood_019606_BD.jpg) Cinemax (MPEG-2) ![[Image: Robin_Hood_019606_Cinemax.jpg]](https://s22.postimg.cc/b4c5ivxk1/Robin_Hood_019606_Cinemax.jpg) TMC (AVC) ![[Image: Robin_Hood_019606_TMC.jpg]](https://s22.postimg.cc/k0mxmto69/Robin_Hood_019606_TMC.jpg) Cosmopolitan Channel (thanks to Kyaneos) (AVC, I presume) ![[Image: Robin.ts_snapshot_00.13.37_2017.05.15_17.31.00.png]](https://s1.postimg.cc/rpfl575bj/Robin.ts_snapshot_00.13.37_2017.05.15_17.31.00.png) DVD ![[Image: Robin_Hood_019606_DVD.jpg]](https://s21.postimg.cc/fj0gx7t6f/Robin_Hood_019606_DVD.jpg) LD (PAL IT) ![[Image: Robin_Hood_019606_LD_it.jpg]](https://s21.postimg.cc/maqw02i5z/Robin_Hood_019606_LD_it.jpg) 
Posts: 2,799
Threads: 49 Joined: 2015 Apr Thanks: 2244
Given 502 thank(s) in 415 post(s) Country: 
2017-05-05, 09:30 PM
I had it and spent hours correcting the colour timing over on OT and I got shouted down and then a pc crash killed it
|
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
