Hello!

I just joined the forum because I am interested in classics from before my time that have aged well but sadly been treated unfairly by upscales and HD re-releases.

I really enjoy these projects that are keeping the original colours and increased fidelity

Are you curious to see the differen color grading, or aspect raio, of a movie, but don't want to watch it all? Well, just take a look at "a whole film in an image" GIFs and screenshot comparisons!

**(warning: big images, it could take some time to load'em all!)**

Title (year) [project] - differences - release date - GIF image - comparison link

Alien (1979) [Fundamental Collection #001] - colors, 85% of movie with bigger frame - 2017-04-18

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/205713

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/208270

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/205715

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/205716

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/209152

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/205656

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/209196

https://diff.pics/kaa5w6EoYgZd/1

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/202787

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/216927

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/217122

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/203166

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/217121

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/216696

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/201928

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/207997

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/205702

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/216411

Inspired by idea of this OT thread, and from the 70mm film frame found there, and because I'm tinkering a lot with color grading lately, I've decide to give it a go...





The colormatched version found in the middle is produced, according to the original poster, using the LUT obtained by Dr. Dre's tool; the matched frame is almost perfect, while this result is a quite a bit far from it... maybe it's due to an old version? dunno... my "inspired" version is closer.

Why "inspired by 70mm"? Because at first I tried to get an image as close as possible to the film frame; but, when I reached an almost perfect result, even if it worked well for the same scene, it worked not so well in many other ones - in particular, clipped whites problem. So, I decided for a compromise, and this time it works very well with the whole movie - still got to watch it all, though, so for the moment the opinion is based on still frames - http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/124259 - and few short clips... let's wait for the whole movie to be regraded and I'll tell you more.

I've briefly compared the HDTV version - which is all 2.40:1 - and, like PDB wrote in another thread, it seems that the IMAX shots are just cropped, more or less perfectly at center... so, I'd add a YAO hack to get a letterbox version.

I know it's not a classic but is there any interest in a HD Theatrical cut? It seems the only official HD release has been the Director's cut (even on DVHS)

I've got a 1080i HDTV cap of the theatrical cut, it shouldn't be too much work to return the TC scenes into the official Blu, synced to the DVD's DTS/AC3 (or possibly the cinema DTS).

I've been doing a lot of digging around with regards to these blanket tints that a lot of Blu Rays tend to receive, especially with regards to those which have a DCP cinema release which is unaffected despite coming from the same master/restoration (obvious examples are The Terminator and Aliens). In doing so I've come across various forum threads and articles regarding the DCI colour space P3 and it's white point which is noticably green. Just search for 'P3 white point' and a ton of stuff comes up. This thread in particular stood out:

http://www.liftgammagain.com/forum/index...oint.1326/ 

I'm guessing something is happening on the conversion to Rec709, ie the white point has not been compensated, resulting in green whites. Once the discussion starts going into xyz values my brain goes a bit mushy but I'm sure there are members here who can make more sense of this.

I've capped the bit-perfect PCM and AC3 soundtracks from the Criterion Collection release of Trainspotting (CC1477L). They have been synced to the US Lionsgate BD and as such will sync with The Aluminium Falcon's Custom BD.

PM For mega download links, this will be available to active members of the forum only.

• 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) Special Edition #60 (Uncut) [LD] [CC1160L] - sourced from 35mm master, which was a printdown of the original 70mmCinerama negative, but in same 2.20:1 aspect ratio
  
• Akira: Special Edition (1988) LBX, USA - 1992 release [LD] [CC1294L]
  
• American Werewolf in London [LD] [34679]
  
• [/url]Atlantic City [LD] 34711
  
• Black Christmas (1974) LBX, USA - 1999 release [LD] [11590]
  
• Bringing Up Baby (1938) [LD] [ID3219TU] - print sourced, possibly from a fine grain source archived
  
• Close Encounters of the Third Kind: Special Edition (1980) LBX, UK [LD] [LD 10003]
  
• Doctor Zhivago (1965) LBX, USA - 1991 release [LD] [ML101526]
  
• Earthquake (1974) [LD] [42072]
  
• Evil Dead, The (1981) [LD] [SF078-5044]
  
• Forgotten Tune for the Flute, A (1988) [LD] [ID7194FR]
  
• Getaway, The (1972) LBX, USA - 1995 release [LD] [11122]
  
• Ghostbusters (1984) [LD] [LD 13119]
  
• Go west [LD](ML102561)
  
• Incident at Blood Pass (1970) [LD] [AD098-039]
  
• It's a Wonderful Life (1946) Special Edition #18 [LD] [CC1112L] - sourced from fine grain negative
  
• Nausicaa of the Valley of Wind (1984) LBX, Japan - 1984 release [LD][98LX-1]
  
• Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors [LD] 07136
  
• North by Northwest #45A (1959) [LD] [CC1226L]
  
• Olympia: Fest der Völker/Fest der Schönheit (1938) [LD] [IVCL-1015W]
  
• Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid (1973) (Uncut) [LD] [ML102238] - sourced from Sam Peckinpah's personal print which he had to steal from the studio and keep in his garage. Only version that exists of uncut film, and same sourced used for DVd version
  
• Pink Panther, The (1963) [LD] [ML102108] - seems to be anamorphic 35mm instead of a Technirama print
  
• Shot in the Dark, A: Pink Panther (1964) [LD] [ML102110]
  
• Silent Rage (1982) [LD] [VLD-5549]
  
• Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan (1982) [LD] [LVG 2062]
  
• Ten Commandments, The: 35th Anniversary (1956) LBX, USA - 1992 release [LD][[url=http://www.lddb.com/laserdisc/21955/LV12971-3WS/]LV12971-3WS]
  
• Terminator  (1984) LBX, USA - 1991 release [LD] [ID8316HD]
  
• Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory: 25th Anniversary [LD] [14546]
  

I thought I'd start a new thread for this so folks could discuss it more.

1. Has anyone else purchased either of the new Bluray sets?
2. Which one or did you get the Legacy Steelbook set?
3. What did or didn't you enjoy about Spiderman 3, the Editor's Cut?
4. Any fan edit ideas for this trilogy?

And go ..........................

The Colorist Wrote:Directors Joel & Ethan Coen and cinematographer Roger Deakins had the entire film scanned and digitally color graded at Cinesite in Los Angeles.

“It was shot in Mississippi in the summer, when it was green and lush,” says Bogdanowicz, “but they wanted a postcard sepia look. They went to a lab and tried to find some sort of process to get the feel they wanted, but they couldn’t achieve it. Color timers in a traditional lab would have used a heavy yellow-red color correction, which would have changed the blue in the sky and the denim jeans. So, the only way to achieve the look was digitally. Cinesite did a chroma-key on the green and turned it to brown gold.” -> link